The Ultimate Superheroines Forum

Between the following, which one is the closest to who could act convincingly in a superheroine sex video?

Lynda Carter's Wonder Woman
Adrianne Palicki's Wonder Woman
Gal Gadot's Wonder Woman
Helen Slater's Supergirl
Melissa Benoist's Supergirl

It is a combination of costume, body, stature, attitude, confidence, and vulnerability. Who is the champion in meeting this goal?

BY FAR!!!!! Lynda Carter's Wonder Woman

What no love for Yvonne Craig?

Lynda Carter's Wonder Woman

I could actually see Melissa Benoist all breathless in a first time lesbian encounter where an older more experienced woman introduces her to a whole new world...in costume!!!

Lynda Carter all the way

JohnFeer wrote:What no love for Yvonne Craig?

I second this motion.

Don't seem right to leave out the lady who literally started it all.

(Granted, Yvonne Craig's acting career was the shortest out of all of them... I think by her '30s she'd quit and gone into real estate.)

Add my name to the chorus clamouring for Yyvonne Craig. The girl had a self-assured cockiness most of the time but wide-eyed innocence about her at times when she was in peril that you just can't quantify.

Benoist would be a close second if only because her nudes prove she's got a seriously freaky side underneath all that innocence.

I'd go with Lynda Carter as well

Now that Wonder Woman is canonically bisexual and Gal Gadot has done a major makeout scene (with Isla Fisher in Keeping Up With The Joneses), let's combine the two and get Gal writhing her gorgeous body all over another Amazon in the second WW film.

Also in Gotham City Sirens, a sex scene between Margot Robbie (Harley Quinn) and Megan Fox (who has been seriously considering playing Poison Ivy). I think Margot would play peril great as well.

Lynda Carter by far. He KO scenes were shown in full (unlike MB in Supergirl) and she had lots of them. Plus you can't beat her innocence and beauty, not to mention the most awesome bod of all shown. Yvonne Craig and Bgirl would be a distant second.

I'd throw in the Markie Post version of Electra Woman, too. Her version was a sexed out, washed up drunk with a bitter attitude. I could easily see her doing fetish.

avenger wrote:I'd throw in the Markie Post version of Electra Woman, too. Her version was a sexed out, washed up drunk with a bitter attitude. I could easily see her doing fetish.

YES!

Honestly, I don't think I'll quote anyone until the holiday is over. The quote box is unreadable.

I agree with the Markie Post costume. She's a hot woman and it had that little boob window. The Dynagirl outfit wasn't bad either. Plus Post has that right amount of mature woman sass.

Her ex ran away with Dyna Girl and her favorite vibrator and she's "had bigger things than that up my ---"

Yes that pilot was fantastic. Wished they'd have done the series.
Plus the 'new' Dyna girl was a total babe.
My favourite line was Aquaman bemoaning the fact that the cafeteria was serving Halibut

Markie gets my vote too

It depends on the tone of the video. Lynda Carter's WW would perform best in a campy fetish video, while Adrianne Palicki's WW looks like she could do some really grim hardcore stuff with everything including the kitchen sink stuffed up her anus.

Heroine Addict wrote:It depends on the tone of the video. Lynda Carter's WW would perform best in a campy fetish video, while Adrianne Palicki's WW looks like she could do some really grim hardcore stuff with everything including the kitchen sink stuffed up her anus.

Quite possibly the least erotic thing ever said on this forum

tallyho wrote:

Heroine Addict wrote:It depends on the tone of the video. Lynda Carter's WW would perform best in a campy fetish video, while Adrianne Palicki's WW looks like she could do some really grim hardcore stuff with everything including the kitchen sink stuffed up her anus.

Quite possibly the least erotic thing ever said on this forum

That sounds like a challenge.

Now now, lets not derail this thread (my apologies Jenny)

If Markie Post's Electra Woman and Adrianne Palicki's Wonder Woman are being considered, then I'll bring Ellie Wood Walker's Wonder Woman to the table of unbroadcastable superheroines. She properly looked like she belonged on one of the less successful clips4sale stores that occasionally does a superheroine video in a cheap party costume.

Also, aren't we overlooking Cathy Lee Crosby's Wonder Woman? After all, her version of WW was actually broadcast on TV. Even though she was just 29 at the time, Cathy hard a worn-in "old lady face" that made her look considerably more mature and MILFy.

I never heard of Ellie Wood Walker, so googled her. She reminds me of Olivia Munn's Wonder Woman, and I love Olivia Munn. So I humbly submit Olivia Munn.

JennyFromTheBlock wrote:Between the following, which one is the closest to who could act convincingly in a superheroine sex video?

Lynda Carter's Wonder Woman
Adrianne Palicki's Wonder Woman
Gal Gadot's Wonder Woman
Helen Slater's Supergirl
Melissa Benoist's Supergirl

It is a combination of costume, body, stature, attitude, confidence, and vulnerability. Who is the champion in meeting this goal?

Lynda Carter without a doubt. She's meets everything in the list that you described...I mean, she has the looks and the woman has been knocked out with gas and chloroform more times than I can count.

Pity the bad girls didn't get a place on the list...Julie Newmar would win hands down, imo.

Lynda Carter also has the most spectacular body, too. That body begs for a costume to be ripped off her.

I'd say Melissa Benoist's Supergirl.

Maybe a side topic but I think Dawn Wells would have been a great Batgirl.

Up against Tina Louise as Poison Ivy in that great "Fourth Season of Batman" that eternally plays in our imagination...

JF

Remember, the rules of Batmain '66 recasting state that the fourth season Batgirl actress must bear no physical resemblance whatsoever to Yvonne Craig.

Mr Freeze changed height, build, hairline and nationality. Twice!
The Riddler gained weight, lost height and grew a mustache.
Catwoman also lost height and somehow changed race.

The only time a recasting was credible was the '66 movie Catwoman. But then they messed it up by making it a huge plot point that Batman couldn't recognize Catwoman without her mask. Even though she hardly ever wore a mask in Season 1.

DonShip wrote:I never heard of Ellie Wood Walker, so googled her. She reminds me of Olivia Munn's Wonder Woman, and I love Olivia Munn. So I humbly submit Olivia Munn.

I fully support Olivia Munn's nomination.

I gotta be honest. I like the options, but I'd throw Michelle Lintel as Black Scorpion in the mix. She was sexy as Hell, and that shortlived series was rife with peril. And next to Lynda's Wonder Woman, it was the most revealing.

Don't get me wrong. It was a TERRIBLE show. But it was a real treat for peril fans, as well as anybody who enjoys the campy stuff.

If we're talking just the options, above, I have to say Lynda. There are numerous examples to cite, but her fighting the gorilla, and her first chloro scene, are all I really need to mention.

LeeCarl wrote:I gotta be honest. I like the options, but I'd throw Michelle Lintel as Black Scorpion in the mix. She was sexy as Hell, and that shortlived series was rife with peril. And next to Lynda's Wonder Woman, it was the most revealing.

Don't get me wrong. It was a TERRIBLE show. But it was a real treat for peril fans, as well as anybody who enjoys the campy stuff

Lintel is another good choice. That body of hers is incredible and the suit was so revealing. The bad guys just about licked their lips every time they saw her or had her in their clutches and the dialogue was full of innuendo. Lintel also has probably the most expressive mouth out of anyone already mentioned above. She more than deserves her place here.

Well I have to admit, Lintel as Black Scorpion is by the far the best response on this thread. I had forgotten all about her, and yet you are spot on.

Lintel as Black Scorpion shall not be considered as a valid contestant because the Black Scorpion tv series was actually a superheroine sex video disguised as a Roger Corman Show. The only thing you need to do is hire a professional producer in order to add the obvious deleted sex/humiliation sequences the great genius probably keep it for him self in the never released blue ray edition.

I wish we had a rebooted version of Black Scorpion with Katie McGrath as the main character or at least a custom video version with an actress that looks like her.

Adrianne Palicki's Wonder Woman