Beauty or Athleticism?

[emile]

Here’s a question: which is more important to you, that a superheroine look beautiful or that she has a strong and athletic body?

What makes her defeat more appealing?

[ThatOnePervert]

I'd say beauty, but honestly I have pretty varied taste in women so that's a pretty low bar to meet. I like a nice BBW so while I also appreciate more toned or muscular girls as well, it's not a requirement to be an attractive heroine.

I think more than anything it's the attitude that's important to me, the courage to go put on a brightly colored outfit and declare to any evil doer that she's there to foil their plans. Watching that confidence turn into arousal, humiliation and/or submission is the hot part.

[Maskripper]

You ask like beauty and a strong, athletic body would be opposites that exclude each other.
I think a strong, athletic body makes a heroine more believable, especially if she doesn't have superpowers.
For example, if you have a Catwoman who is like 5 feet tall and weighs 100 pounds ... (and has a horrid costume and "mask") it's really "unrealistic" and uncool for me, like in a certain movie.
She is tiny, thin, and short-haired... she doesn't check one of the 2 categories you mentioned for me. (and yeah, I know Catwoman isn't a 100% heroine)
Of course, if the superheroine looks like a female version of 80's Schwarzenegger... it's too "much" for me. But that risk is really low.
So I would go for a beautiful, strong woman who can do a good number of pushups and has an athletic body.

I vote for... "both"

[argento]

Being athletic does not detract from beauty, and vice versa. It is logical for superheroines to be athletic. Take Wonder Woman as an example; she wakes up with a sword and shield in hand, having undergone Greco-Roman style training. Therefore, she must have muscles, but this does not diminish her beauty. Ana Ivanovic is a prime example of this balance; not only is she among the top ten most beautiful tennis players, but she was also a former world number one.
When it comes to pornography, many people prefer performers with large breasts and a big buttocks, but there are exceptions like Sasha Grey. Despite having small breasts, Sasha's charisma and exceptional personality made her successful.
Ultimately, personal taste is subjective and it is difficult to determine the exact demands of the market. It may be best to consult with producers who sell videos to gain insight into the market's preferences.

[PartsUnknown]

Athletic bodies are beautiful to me, so they’re not mutually exclusive.

[DonShip]

Beauty

[Dazzle1]

Here’s a question: which is more important to you, that a superheroine look beautiful or that she has a strong and athletic body?

What makes her defeat more appealing?

I think a Superheroine must have an athletic body, just as a superheroine with a beer belly does not make sense

[UncleBingo]

Here’s a question: which is more important to you, that a superheroine look beautiful or that she has a strong and athletic body?

What makes her defeat more appealing?

[IMSancho]

New Phoenix Filmworks always seemed to have a good combination of both.

[heroinehunter]

Athleticism.

I was always more drawn to a physically fit body in women. Enjoying zfx-shockwave, I liked Tabitha Jordan and Penelope Pace because they were both fit. You can tell they exercised. A girl can be beautiful, but if she has a 'beer gut' or flabby legs...nope.

[sneakly]

It depends on what you mean by “athletic.” MTG is athletic, but unattractive. Jamie Presley is attractive and athletic. If we are talking about action heroines or superheroines, a tight, athletic body is preferred, but she doesn’t need to be overly big and muscular A heroine, IMHO, relies more on smarts, speed and agility rather than bulk and muscle. I like petit, well proportioned women.

[Dazzle1]

It depends on what you mean by “athletic.” MTG is athletic, but unattractive. Jamie Presley is attractive and athletic. If we are talking about action heroines or superheroines, a tight, athletic body is preferred, but she doesn’t need to be overly big and muscular A heroine, IMHO, relies more on smarts, speed and agility rather than bulk and muscle. I like petit, well proportioned women.

In my case, if a woman is not toned and fit; she really can't be a superheroine.

She can do other erotica and be sexy.

But think of all the D.C or Marvel superheroines, even the Magic Users they are all fit